Peer Review Form

REVIEWER INFORMATION

Reviewer First Name

Reviewer Last Name

Reviewer Email

Title of Reviewed Submission

SUBMISSION QUESTIONS

Is the article intellectually sound? Is there a compelling thesis that engages existing literature? Are there topics and themes missing that should be addressed in this article?

Does this contribution address a concern that is important to SOULS' audiences? If not, please suggest revisions that might shift this work to be of interest to readers.

Are the arguments well supported and thoroughly documented? Are claims substantiated in citations?

Are the ideas and political contexts that this article discusses accessible to audiences not familiar with the particular terrain? If not, please suggest revisions that support greater accessibility.

How would you rate/describe the overall quality and thoroughness of the article? Is the work organized and written with clarity?

How well does this article address the themes of this special issue?

Is this research an intervention within the intellectual tradition it engages, and if so, can you elaborate on the nature of the intervention?

Please list comments for the author below:

Please list comments for the editor below. These will not be shared outside of the editorial team: